Why Writers Should Get Over Pop Music

iStockphoto / dblight

Pop music is the worst thing that could happen to your writing. It’s for dates and bad wedding receptions. Turn it off at once.

Pop is designed to structure your ideas. Stereo hearts in the dark with pumped up kicks. And it works far too well for a writer’s good. As Noel Coward told us, it’s extraordinary how potent cheap music is.

Contemporary classical music, the genius of today’s living composers, will set you free.

Shake out some of the sand that’s in your hair when you come in off the dunes of life. Mess with your best nitties. Line up your finest gritties. You know what we’re doing, don’t you? Well, of course you do. Get them in the right order and others can read what you were thinking. Even feel what you were feeling. These are words. And this is writing. It’s what we do.

But why not engage an even higher alchemy?

Living composers, gorgeous and serious creatures with racing-quick wits—not old dead white guys in breeches—arrive dusted in the same nuggets of concept and emotion we writers wear. Same world as ours, after all. But they super-heat what sticks to them into a new substance.

High-silica content: composers’ material moves through time. And this is your hours’ glass.

Contemporary classical music wraps your efforts to fuse thought and emotion in a see-through composite. Clear aesthetic possibility. As your words rush through that glassy focused space-space they create with their music, you may or may not share a single concept with your composer. Doesn’t matter. The transparency of her or his medium opens windows in your work, shifting your sands with new breezes of sonic intelligence.

Three samples for writerly tasks

Brainstorming: “TransAmerica” is about rapid mind movement with pushy percussion, full of knockabout switchbacks. Todd Reynolds is one of our most accomplished digital violinists. He tours internationally in performance of his own work and that of composer-colleagues. Here’s more about the guy many of us know on Twitter as “DigiFiddler,” who also founded one of New York’s most acclaimed amped string quartets, Ethel. Click here to listen if you don’t see the slider below; go to the 2nd slider on the page. (Audio from Q2 Music.)

Crafting: “Oceanic Verses” starts very quietly and searches the horizon, tentative and patient. Composer Paola Prestini is a wonder. The calls of her strings remind me of the great Greek composer Eleni Karaindrou’s lonely siren echoes. And Prestini loves writers: “Literature has played a huge role in my writing and it has always been my first collaborator; I love painting music on literary canvases; ideas on the page invite me to play and to think.” Click here to listen if you don’t see the slider below. (Audio from Q2 Music.)

Revising: “Everything Is an Onion” is careful, purposeful, measured, dutiful. Yeah, like peeling it. You undo one edit and look what happens to three other phrases in the same chapter, right? Timo Andres works his keyboard, as you do yours, with personable intensity. It’s what caused critic Alex Ross to call “Shy and Mighty,” Andres’ debut recording, “more mighty than shy.” And as your revisions stretch out into something past a natural lifespan (don’t they always?), it’s comforting to know that this piece is from a lengthier work titled “It Takes a Long Time To Be a Good Composer.” Click here to listen if you don’t see the slider below; go to the 2nd slider on the page. (Audio from Q2 Music.)

Stump the Porter

Make a deal with you. Turn off that Beyoncé before your ears glaze over, and tell me in a comment below what sort of scene or situation or mess you’ve written yourself into. I’ll get back to you with a suggestion of a living composer whose work may just help you hear your way around the next corner in your manuscript.

And tell me what you think: is there a time and place for pop in serious writing? What’s your favorite music for various writing tasks? How do you use music in conjunction with your writing? Or do you use it at all? If not, what’s the matter with you?

Porter Anderson—whose Writing on the Ether appears here at JaneFriedman.com on Thursdays—has issued a matching grant to Q2 Music listeners who donate during the autumn pledge drive through October 26. You do NOT have to pledge a penny. This is not a pitch. Porter’s much more interested in bringing together new music with new writings. If you do feel interested in contributing to the work of this unique NPR affiliate (an online streaming service of WNYC/WQXR in New York), each $1 you donate will be matched with $1 from Porter, up to a total of $5,000, at Q2Music.org. And Porter would love to thank you. Drop him a line on Twitter.

  • Ekari Mbvundula

    Music has definitely contributed to many of my more passionate ideas. Excellent post! My favorite was TransAmerica. It evoked so many images that are just waiting to be strung together in a plot!

  • Pingback: Pop music ruins your brain, but so does contemporary classical pap | Laura Roberts

  • http://twitter.com/drardal Ardal Powell

    I am musically handicapped: having grown up a musician and the son of musicians, music absorbs my full attention and I still can’t listen with only half an ear. I’m the pest who asks for the ambient restaurant soundtrack to be turned down so I can hear the conversation; I flee retail environments infected with thumping trash-sound; music while driving makes me miss my exit … The only thing I can do while music sounds is ironing. The tracks posted here are well worth the listening–which I will do after work, in full. Thanks for posting them!

  • http://literating.wordpress.com/ Lancelot

    Have you tried Eric Whitacre? He’s amazing.

  • http://twitter.com/Porter_Anderson Porter Anderson

    Indeed, @EricWhitacre:twitter  is one of my favorite people, I know him and like his music a great deal. He’s in Bilbao next month and Rome in December, you know. Did you know his wife is @HilaPlitmann:disqus  ? — Terrific soprano. She’s featured in this recording of Christopher Theofanidis’ The Here and Now, wonderful work http://ow.ly/77z1u and she did the voices for @HansZimmerMusic:twitter ‘s Da Vinci Code soundtrack. Eric and Hila are super. Have you heard his new CD?  http://ow.ly/77zej

    **This comment written while listening to Son of Chamber Symphony by John Adams on @Q2Music:twitter

  • http://twitter.com/Porter_Anderson Porter Anderson

    Super range of eras and styles here, @Shannon:disqus , glad you mentioned the Gershwins and @ChrisBotti:twitter (he’s incredible). You’re right, so much to listen to. :) Thanks for reading and commenting.

  • http://twitter.com/Porter_Anderson Porter Anderson

    We’re giving @DigiFiddler:twitter a big head here, lol.  Hey, Ekari, sorry not to get back to you sooner (you guys have outdone yourselves on comments!!). So glad  you like “Transamerica,” isn’t it grand? Remember, it’s part of Todd Reynolds’ album “Outerborough,” his first solo outing. (Can you believe that work is solo?) http://ow.ly/77DTN  — a fine achievement.  And I’m sure we’d all like to hear what becomes of that plot you’re thinking of working up from it. Do keep us informed. I’m always (and I mean always) at @Porter_Anderson:twitter on Twitter and here at the generous @JaneFriedman:twitter ‘s concert hall every Thursday. Thanks for commenting!

    **This comment written while listening to Gavin Bryars’ landmark Jesus’ Blood Never Failed Me on @Q2Music:twitter

  • http://twitter.com/Porter_Anderson Porter Anderson

    Hey, Ardal, know exactly what you mean. I’m still amazed that we’re supposed to shop for food in supermarkets playing 60-year-old rock music. :)   I’m listening to the most beautiful guitar work right now on Q2, you might like it, too. The sort of thing to stop and pay attention to completely, a work called Koyunbaba, “Homage to a saint,” by the great Italian guitarist and composer Carlo Domeniconi (now in his early 60s). Gorgeous work. The guitarist is Celia Linde. It’s on this album, in case you’re interested: http://ow.ly/77EkH  Thanks for reading and for commenting — and all the best with that handicap, and for listening to my little playlist here, too. Cheers!

    **This comment written while listening to the Domeniconi on @Q2Music:twitter  

  • Terre Britton

    Porter, such a terrific article. Your reference to alchemy
    is apt. That sacred mix of creation: laying yourself bare to inspiration—from
    one source or another—and dancing the dervish with your Muse. Pure magic!

     

    I’m with Cyndi Pauwels, I can’t write to music that has
    lyrics, with the exception that you mentioned, Porter: certain choral
    arrangements, where the voices become instruments, themselves. (Listening to
    music while painting is an entirely different story.)

     

    I started listening to classical and opera in college,
    because 80’s music held little interest for me. I fell in love with Vivaldi
    & Rossini, and know the Italian libretto to Verdi’s “Va Pensiero” and rave
    over Sherrill Milne’s version of “Largo Al Factotum.” When I discovered
    @Q2music, my music paradigm was shifted. College/university had introduced me
    to a small wave of performance art, where I worked with two musicians: a
    cellist and percussionist–who played ‘found objects.’ But the scope of sounds
    and talent Q2 offers is like a tsunami in comparison.

     

    It was Gavin Bryars’ “Live @Guggenheim: The Sinking of the
    Titanic,” that made me stand up and take notice. Then, about a month ago, Lisa
    Batiashvili playing Giya Kancheli’s “V&V” and John Cage, in the performance
    “The Space Between,” unraveled a stress? Soothed a nerve? Pricked a passion?
    With “V&V,” my consciousness was arrested and my way of ‘seeing’ was
    changed.  All hail, John Berger!

     

    And, I have this crazy habit of listening to a single piece,
    repeatedly, until I ‘know’ each note. Assimilate it. I can’t tell you how often
    I’ve listened to the works above, plus “Temple of Dendur,” “Johnny Greenwood,”
    and “Spiegel im Spiegel.”

     

    But I think, as others have noted, everyone responds
    creatively to different stimuli: be it contemporary-classic, pop, and everything in-between. Some people love ‘nature’ sounds. We are all wired
    differently. For me, much of the music on Q2 becomes a part of me as I write or
    paint. It moves from a background sound into part of the potion. And it is
    powerful.

     

    Thanks again for such a thought-provoking post, Porter. And
    thank you for introducing me to, both, @Q2music and @WQXRClassical.

     

    [I wrote this comment listening to “V&V,” Karsh Kale’s
    “Crawl, Walk, Run,” and Missy Mazzoli’s “Adore, into the Dark (sp?).”]

  • http://twitter.com/Porter_Anderson Porter Anderson

    Thanks for all the input, Terre, and the great account of your experience of Q2 Music. While I approach Q2 mainly as a writer/listener, when I look at it from the critic’s standpoint, I think what we’re seeing (and what you’re responding to) is a very unusual lucky confluence of an amazing amount of compositional talent. Much of it’s based in New York, but there are hubs, of course, in Reykjavik and Rome, London, and other spots. The really happy aspect of this big Montmartre-in-the-making is that Q2 Music has been perfectly timed by its parent, WQXR, to not only catch this bubble of talent but provide it with a worldwide audience. No one has to live in Manhattan or Brooklyn to participate and benefit from this development, making it easily as good for the audience as it is for the composers. (At least 40 percent of Q2′s audience is not in New York — not many NPR affiliates can claim that sort of long-distance, let alone global, listenership). So we’re seeing, in my opinion, a special configuration of tech and art meet in the right time and place. Hence my move to try to be sure Q2 gets the funding it needs and can mature in its mission. After two years, the service has more than proved its efficacy and simply will need adequate resources and positioning from WQXR to keep moving forward. The growth of its archive of live performances, alone, is a masterful asset, so important for the documentation and preservation of much of this new work. Thanks again, and enjoy –

    **This comment written while listening to @TimoAndres:twitter ‘ “It Takes a Long Time To Become a Good Composer” on @Q2Music:twitter , played by the composer, a private recording.

  • Ekari Mbvundula

    Wow, the comment format is ca-raaaazy! Lol, but luckily I eventually found your reply.

    TransAmerica seemed to awaken in my mind scenes of dancing/fighting/fighting-that-looks-like-dancing between two beautiful people, the pacing going fast and slow as the music does. Their story could be one of betrayal – or maybe one of them doesn’t want to fight the other, but has to because of external forces. So they’re torn between their duties and not wanting to hurt each other… hehe, I think thats the playwright in me talking now!

    I’m following you on twitter now, and I will check out your other musical recommendations. Otherwise, welcome to my blog any time: http://ekarimbvundula.blogspot.com

  • http://www.thefourorders.com Terre Britton

    Thanks for the background on Q2; online radio has certainly taken long strides over the past few years. Being a semi-geek attached to my computer at the wrists for the greater part of each day, I’m grateful for the ubiquitous sounds of Q2 that stream through my headphones or BOSE and carry, or drive, me forward. 
    Thanks again for introducing me to such fine musicians, composers and knowledgeable hosts.
    All the best,
    Terre

  • Pingback: Writer Unboxed » ‘Social’ media: What isn’t in a name